So What Do You Do, Tina Gaudoin, Editor-in-Chief, WSJ.?
WSJ.'s secret weapon blasts the notion that she's driving an ad vehicle
September 12, 2008
On the first weekend of New York Fashion Week, the rather staid Wall Street Journal unveiled its glossier side in the form of new luxury magazine WSJ. It appears at a rather delicate moment in the histories of newspapers, magazines, and The Wall Street Journal itself. Newspapers are tanking, and magazines are struggling to drum up ad pages, but magazines published by newspapers -- especially slick tomes devoted to the luxe life -- are doing gangbusters, the best example The New York Times' style magazine, T. This genre-within-a-genre is by now old hat in London, where the Financial Times's How To Spend It and the Times of London's Luxx have scooped up ad pages for years. That the Journal would choose to launch its own magazine in their molds at this moment is a reflection of the paper's new direction under owner Rupert Murdoch and his deputy, managing editor Robert Thomson. And so is their choice to edit the magazine, Tina Gaudoin.Gaudoin was editing Luxx in London when she was offered the job at WSJ. Planning for a glossy was already underway when her hiring was announced, but the Journal insider widely expected to conceive and edit it was unceremoniously taken off the project. For the last eight months, she has been prepping for her editor-in-chief debut on American shoes, tapping a handful of luxury and lifestyle editors who might otherwise have never been on the paper's radar. Mediabistro spoke with Gaudoin on the eve of the magazine's launch about the culture of the Journal, her tiny staff, and an autobiographical roman a clef -- Not Just Prada: Real Life Adventures In Magazines -- she's proposed but hasn't sold or written about (you guessed it) her adventures in the magazine business. Name: Tina Gaudoin Position: Editor-in-chief, WSJ. Resume: Began as Tatler beauty editor, worked for Liz Tilberis as beauty editor on relaunch of Harper's Bazaar, senior writer at American Vogue, presenter Q2, deputy editor of Tatler, founding editor Frank magazine, feature writer The Times, editorial director iVillage UK, style director of Saturday Times magazine, launch editor Luxx which brings us here... Birthday: January 4 Hometown: Norwich, Norfolk, England Education: BA honors in English literature from Lancaster University Marital status: Married to Ford Ennals First section of the Sunday Times: Page one, then Vows: "I love backstories" Favorite television shows: Grey's Anatomy and re-runs of Black Adder Guilty pleasure: Raisinets and Flipz Last book read: The Size of the World by Joan Sibler
How "British" is WSJ., in the sense that it borrows from the editorial sensibility of Luxx or How To Spend It? How do those magazines compare against luxury titles in the United States, and did you set out to give your magazine that accent? I was very aware I was coming to a huge brand, and a hugely respected brand. I've tried to be very careful with that, and I've tried to be respectful of the Journal reader, who is intelligent, opinionated, and not afraid to share their opinions. The Journal reader is very discerning not only about what they consume in terms of words, but what they consume in terms of product. I have been very careful of that, and I have been very respectful of the Journal's American roots, because I think it would be a mistake to make anything too anglicized. So, no, this is not an anglicized magazine. Does it have an arch sense of humor in some places? Yes it does, which might be slightly more surprising to an American reader who is used to consuming general interest magazines. But no, it is not an Anglophile's magazine.
Were you surprised by the lack of humor in American magazines, and how Americans approach luxury?
What's your favorite story in the first issue, or what story is most representative of what you're trying to do?
How did you go about assembling your staff? Your masthead is notable in the sense that you built a team from scratch from Men's Vogue, Travel + Leisure, Tatler, and House & Garden. Was it your decision to bring in so many outsiders to create this magazine, or were you yourself part of that decision?
How does your staff here compare with your resources running Luxx, and with the famous British magazine model, with much smaller staffs. If I recall correctly, you ran Luxx with six people.
What's the strategic role of WSJ. within the paper and within Dow Jones? One of great ironies of both magazines and newspapers at the moment is that while neither medium seems to be doing particularly well at the moment, lifestyle magazines published by newspapers are advertising magnets. Is your job to create a vehicle for doing the same? Then, if you're asking me, "Do I feel embarrassed about the fact that this is a luxury advertising vehicle?" the answer to your question is: I would be, if it were, but it's not. And I'll tell you why it's not. Our readers are so discerning and so vocal that it is not something they would accept. I didn't set out to create a catalogue of luxury goods that people could buy. I set out to create a magazine about a lifestyle that people might want to participate in.
Why did you accept this assignment, and why were you seemingly the first choice to do it? (If there were other names floated, none were ever leaked to the press.)
A practical question: how should freelancers approach WSJ.? Between your own staffers, the Journal reporters available, and your own openness to freelancers, what should they be pitching you? What percentage of the magazine will be freelance-driven?
How does this experience compare with your stint at Liz Tilberis' Harper's Bazaar? The weight of launching something like this is quite considerable given the brand, given the expectations, and given the readership. This is a tricky job, it's an enjoyable job, but I knew this wasn't going to be easy.
Do you think that your experience at Harper's Bazaar -- the enormous budgets, the stop-at-nothing pursuit of luxury and glamour -- is a thing of the past? Is the essence of editing a magazine today doing more with less?
Please pardon me if I've mistaken you for a different Tina Gaudoin, but Amazon U.K. contains a listing for a book entitled
Not Just Prada: Real Life Adventures in Magazines, by one Tina Gaudoin. Is that you, and if so, what exactly is the book about? Based on the publisher's description, it appears to be a novel about a "Tina" working in magazines.
Greg Lindsay is a frequent contributor to mediabistro.com. [This interview has been edited for length and clarity.] |
||
| > Have a comment? Send a letter to the editor. > Read more in our archives |





